3AKJIIOQEHHE ,1UICCEPTAl(HOHHOrO COBETA,lJ: 209.002.08 HA J>A3E
<l>E,lJ:EPAJIbHOrO rOCY,lJ:APCTBEHHOrO ABTOHOMHOrO
OJ>PA30BATEJIbHOrO yqPElK,lJ:EHIDI BbICIIIErO OJ>PA30BAHIDI
«MOCKOBCKHM rOCY,lJ:APCTBEHHbIM HHCTHTYT
MElKWHAPO,lJ:HbIX OTHOIIIEHHM (YHHBEPCHTET) MHHHCTEPCTBA
HHOCTPAHHbIX ,lJ:EJI POCCHMCKOM <I>E,lJ:EPAl(HH»
ITO ,lJ:HCCEPTAl(HH HA COHCKAHHE yqEHOM CTEITEHH
KAH,lJ:H,lJ:ATA IOPH,lJ:nqECKHX HAYK
aTIeCTa~HOHHoe)].eJIO N!~-----------
peureane )].HccepTa~HoHHoroCOBeTa OT 09.03 2017 NQ 11
a npacyacnenaa Mycradiaeeoa Hanacnfie Hm.rap KbI3bI , A3ep6aM)].:>KaHCKa5I
Pecrryfinaxa, yqeHoM crenenn KaH)].H)].aTa IOpH)].HQeCKHX nayx.
,l:(HccepTa~H5I na resry: «Mcacayuaponao-upaaoeas n03HQHH Aaepfiaiinacaaa
B OTHomeHHH pediopsmpoaauaa OOH» B BH)].e pyxormcn rro Crre~HaJIbHOCTH
12.00.10 - Mexcnyaaponaoe npaso; Eaponeitcxoe npaso rrpHH5ITa K 3alI(HTe
15.12.2016 r. , rrpOTOKOJI NQ 8 zmccepranaonasra COBeTOM ,l:( 209.002.08 na fiase
<I>e)].epaJIbHOrO rocyztapcrnenaoro aBTOHOMHoro 06pa30BaTeJIbHOrO yQpe:>K)].eHH5I
asrcmero 06pa30BaHH5I «MOCKOBCKHM rocynapcraemrsnt HHCTHTyT Me:>K)].yHapo)].HbIX
ornomemni (yHHBepcHTeT) MHHHcTepcTBa nnocrpamrsrx )].eJI POCCHMCKOM
<I>e)].epa~HH» , 119454, Mocxsa, npocnexr Bepnancxoro, 76, yTBep:>K)].eHHbIM rrpHKa30M
MHHHcTepcTBa 06pa30BaHH5I H HayKH POCCHMCKOM <I>e)].epa~HH OT 15.02.2013 r.
NQ 75/HK.
COHCKaTeJIb Mycradiaesa Ha)].:>KH6a Hnsrap KbI3bI, 1987 rona pO:>K)].eHH5I, B 2009
rony OKOHQHJIa AKa)].eMHIO rocyztapcraennoro yrrpaBJIeHH5I npn Ilpesaneirre
A3ep6aM)].:>KaHCKOM Pecrry6JIHKH. B 2013 rozry OKOHQHJIa xraracrparypy <I>e)].epaJIbHOrO
rocynapcrsenaoro 61O)].:>KeTHOrO 06pa30BaTeJIbHOrO yQpe:>K)].eHH5I ssrcurero
06pa30BaHH5I «MOCKOBCKHM rocynapcrsemmii IOpH)].H"lfeCKHM yHHBepcHTeT HMeHH
O.E. Kyradnma» (MrIOA). C 2014 rona rro HaCT05IlI(ee BpeM5I 5IBJI5IeTC5I COHCKaTeJIeM
xadiezrpsr Me:>K)].yHapo)].Horo npasa MrI1MO MI1,l:( POCCHH. C 2012 rona rro HaCT05Imee
2
BpeM}I pafioraer B ):(OJDKHOCTI1 nay-more COTpy):(HI1Ka IJ,eHTpa CTpaTerW:leCKI1X
Hccnenonanaa (IJ,CM) npn Ilpe311):(eHTe A3ep6aH):()ImHCKOH Pecrryfimnor.
,ll;l1ccepTaU;I1}1 BhIIIOnHeHa na xadienpe Me)l():(yHapO):(HOrO npasa <l>e):(epanhHOrO
rocynapcraennoro aBTOHOMHOrO 06pa30BaTenhHOrO yqpe)l():(eHI1}1 BhIClIIerO
06pa30BaHI1}1 «MOCKOBCKI1H rocynapcrneaasrti I1HCTI1TYT Me)l():(yHapO):(HhIX OTHOlIIeHI1H
(YHI1BepCI1TeT) MI1HI1CTepCTBa I1HOCTpaHHhIX zten POCCI1HCKOH <l>e):(epaI.:(I1I1».
HayqHblii pyKoBO,LJ;HTeJIb MaJIeeB IOpHii HHKOJIaeBHq, ):(OKTOp
IOpl1):(l1qeCKI1X nayx, nporpeccop, nporpeccop xadieztpsr Me)l():(yHapO):(HOrO npasa
MrMMO MM,ll; POCCI1I1.
0<l>HQHaJIbHble onnoaen'rsn
MOHCeeB AJIeKCeii AJIeKCaH,LJ;pOBHq - rpaacaamm POCCI1HCKOH <l>e):(epaI.:(l1l1,
):(OKTOp IOpl1):(l1qeCKI1X nayx;
HCnOJIHHOB AJIeKCeii CTaHHCJIaBOBHq - rpaacnanan POCCI1HCKOH <l>e):(epaI.:(l1l1,
KaH):(I1):(aT IOpl1):(I1QeCKI1X nayx, ):(0I.:(eHT, 3aBe):(YIOI.IJ;I1H Kaepe):(pOH Me)l():(yHapO):(HOrO
npaaa IOpl1):(I1QeCKOrO epaKynhTeTa <l>e):(epanhHOrO rocynapcrsenaoro 61O):()I(eTHOrO
06pa30BaTenhHOrO yspeacnemer BhIClIIerO 06pa30BaHI1}1 «MOCKOBCKI1H
rocynapcrsermuii YHI1BepCI1TeT I1MeHI1 M.B. JIOMoHOCOBa»,
ztann nonoaorrem.asre OT3hIBhI na ):(I1CCepTaI.:(l1lO.
Be,LJ;YIQaH OpraHH3aQHH: $e,LJ;epaJIbHOe rocynapcrneunoe 61O,LJ;~eTHOe
06pa30BaTeJIbHOe ynpeacaenae nsrcmero 06pa30BaHHH «,l];HnJIOMaTHqeCKaH
aKa,LJ;eMHH MHHHCTepCTBa HHOCTpaHHblX ,LJ;eJI Poccaiicxoii $e,LJ;epaQHH»,
r. MOCKBa, B CBOeM ncnoaorrem.non 3aKn1OQeHI1I1, rrO):(rrI1CaHHOM KaH):(I1):(aTOM
IOpl1):(I1QeCKI1X nayx, CTaplIIl1M rrpenonaaarenev xadienpsr Me)l():(yHapO):(HOrO npasa
AHI1CI1MOBhIM M.O., ):(OKTOpOM IOpl1):(I1QeCKI1X nayx, nporpeccopoja, 3aBe):(YIOI.IJ;I1M
Kaepe):(pOH Me)l():(yHapO):(HOrO npasa ErOpOBhIM C.A., yTBep)l():(eHHOM rrpopexropov rro
HayQHOH pafiore, ):(OKTOpOM rrOnl1TI1QeCKI1X nayx, npotpeccopov MBaHoBhIM O .IT.,
yxasana, QTO ):(l1ccepTaI.:(110HHOe nccnenoaaane MycTa<!JaeBOH H.M. nanncano aa
axryansnyro TeMy. HaYQHa5I HOBI13Ha ):(l1ccepTaI.:(110HHOrO I1CCne):(OBaHI15I COCTOI1T B
TOM, QTO ):(I1CCepTaHT nponen xoxrnnexcaoe nccnenonanae oco6eHHOCTeH
Me)l():(yHapO):(Ho-rrpaBOBOH rr0311I.:(1111 A3ep6aH):()I(aHa rro sonpocy pe<!JopMhI OOH, a
3
TaK)Ke npeztnoxcun pan peKOMeH,Il,au.MM rro ycoBepweHCTBOBaHMIO OT,Il,enbHbIX BM,Il,OB
,l:(e5lTenbHOCTM OOB.
IIOnO)KMTenbHbIM epaKToM 51Bn5leTC5I TO, qTO COMCKaTenb npMBO,Il,MT B CBOeM
HayqHOM Tpy,Il,e MHOrO nOne3HOM epaKTMqeCKOM MHepOpMaU.MM M npasrepos M3
rrpaB03arn;MTHOM M MMPOTBOpqeCKOM npaKTMKM OOB, CBM,Il,eTenbcTBYIOrn;eM 0
Heo6xo,Il,MMOCTM peepopMMpOBaHM5I ,Il,aHHOM Me)K,Il,yHapO,Il,HOM opraHM3au.MM M COBeTa
Eesonacnocra, B qaCTHOCTM.
OC06bIM mrrepec npertcraanser aaanas ,Il,MCCepTaHToM npaann npouenypsi
COBeTa Eesonacnocrn OOB (c. 81). B ,Il,MCCepTau.MoHHoM MCCne,Il,OBaHMM
paccraarpasaerca rrpaxruxa npMMeHeHM5I rrpasa BeTO (c. 81-87), a TaK)Ke pons
pesomounii COBeTa Besonacaocra. IIpM 3TOM aBTOp orziensnoe BHMMaHMe ynenser
npofineue HeMcnOnHeHM5I pcsornoima BbIweYKa3aHHOrO oprana OOB (c. 88-100).
Cnpaaennas BbIEO,Il, COMCKaTen51 0 TOM, qTO O,Il,HOM M3 epYH,Il,aMeHTallbHbIX sana-r
MMpOBoro coofimecrsa B rexyutev CToneTMM 51Bn5leTC5I Heo6xo,Il,MMOCTb nepexozta OT
npMH5ITIDI MHOrOqMCneHHbIX Me)K,Il,yHapO,Il,HbIX ,Il,OrOBOpOB no npasaa xenoeexa K MX
peansrrovy M sceofiuieay ncnonaeumo. Maorae HOPMbI M rrpanuamr, perynapyioume
crpepy sannrrst npas -renonexa, npaofiperm B COBpeMeHHbIX Me)K,Il,yHapO,Il,HbIX
OTHOWeHM5IX YHMBepCallbHbIM xapaxrep,
OTMeqa51 Ba)KHYIO pons pernoaansnsrx opraaasauna B Me)K,Il,yHapO,Il,HbIX
OTHOWeHM5IX, COMCKaTenb ztenaer 060CHOBaHHbIM BbIEO,Il, 0 TOM, qTO OHM npMMeH5IIOT
HeTpa,Il,Mu.MOHHbIe nO,Il,XO,Il,bI, a onsrr 3epepeKTMBHoro ocyutecraneaaa npeBeHTMBHbIX
CTpaTerMM, naxonneaasrii B O,Il,HOM peraoHe, MO)KeT 6bITb pacnpocrpanen no sceny
MMpy(c.140).
IIpM ofimer«, HeCOMHeHHO, BbICOKOM yposne pa60TbI B 3aKnlOqeHMM
cdiopsrynaponan pan 3aMeqaHMM.
Bo-rrepssrx, Ha3BaHM5I nexoropsrx rnas M naparpadios He HOC5IT
MHcPopMaTMBHoro xapaxrepa M fionsme rrO,Il,XO,Il,51T ,Il,n51 3aronOBKOB nay-msrx crareii,
qeM ,Il,n51 KaH,Il,M,Il,aTCKOM ,Il,MCCepTau.MM, narrpasrep: «Tnasa 1. OOB: BbI30BbI
cOBpeMeHHocTM M Heo6xo,Il,MMOCTb perpopnr.r», «1.1. Perpopsra OOB B
rn06allM3MpYIOrn:eMc5I MMpe: nepcnexrnssi C03,Il,aHM5I «srapoaoro npaaarenscrsa»,
4
«1.2. K HOBOH KOMrreTeHl.l}UI OOH», «Tnana 3 . Perpopxia OOH: MMp M npasa
qeJIOBeKa».
BO-BTOPbIX, He.n;OCTaTKOM pa60TbI 5IBJI5IeTC5I OTCyTcTBMe aHaJIM3a .n;e5ITeJIbHOCTM
OOH B 06JIaCTM Me)l{.n;yHapo.n;Horo corpynan-recrsa rro TpaHCrpaHMqHoMy
MCrrOJIb30BaHMIO MHTepHeTa. BMeCTe C TeM, .n;aHHa5I crpepa .n;e5ITeJIbHOCTM ocofienno
axryansna B CBeTe yCMJIeHM5I KM6eprrpecTyrrHocTM M napymemrn npas qeJIOBeKa. B
:n OH CB5I3M XOTeJIOCb 6bI yaazterr. paccyacneaaa asropa 0 Heo6xo.n;MMOCTM
perpopvnpoaaaas TaKMX CTpyKTypHbIX 06pa30BaHMH OOH, KaK: Koop.n;MHaU:MoHHbIH
COBeT pyxoaoznrreneti CMCTeMbI OOH, Tpyrma OOH rro MH<)JopMaU:MoHHoMy
ofimecrsy, <f>OpyM rro MCrrOJIb30BaHMIO MHTepHeTa M T .zt,
Bvrpcrsnx, B TeKCTe zmcceprauaa COMCKaTeJIb rrOCT05IHHO MCrrOJIb3yeT TepMMH
«MMpoBoe rrpaBMTeJIbCTBo» (c. 5, 8, 12, 23 M T .zt.). Tlorraraesr, qTO 6bIJIO 6bI yxiecrno
rtars rr05ICHeHMe, qTO asrop rrOHMMaeT non .n;aHHbIM TepMMHOM.
B-qeTBepTblx, B CB5I3M C 06MJIMeM ncnonsayerar.rx coxpanienaa B TeKCTe
zmccepranna, qTO HeM36e)l{HO npa nanacanaa KaqeCTBeHHOH pa60TbI B 06JIaCTM npasa
Me)l{.n;yHapo.n;HbIX opraHM3aU:MH, 6bIJIO 6bI )l{eJIaTeJIbHO rrpMBeCTM crrMCOK YCJIOBHbIX
0603HaqeHMH M coxpautenaii.
B 3aKJIIOQeHMe B OT3bIBe OTMeQeHO, QTO znrccepratnor 5IBJI5IeTC5I
caMOCT05ITeJIbHbIM, 3aKOHQeHHbIM, KOMrrJIeKCHbIM MCCJIe.n;OBaHMeM, BHOC5Iru:MM BKJIa.n; B
pa3BMTMe cospeaeanoro Me)l{.n;yHapo.n;Horo npasa, npasa Me)l{.n;yHapo.n;HbIX
opraHM3aU:MH, B qaCTHOCTM. AKTYaJIbHOCTb BbI6paHHoH asropoxr TeMbI nozrrsepacneua,
nay-nrsre rrOJIO)l{eHM5I, BbIBO.n;bI M pexonenaanan, C<)JOpMyJIMpOBaHHble B .n;MccepTaU:MM,
rrpe.n;cTaBJI5IIOTC5I BrrOJIHe 06ocHoBaHHbIMM, a MX ztocroaepaocn, M HOBM3Ha He
BbI3bIBaIOT COMHeHMH. Pe3YJIbTaTbI nncceprarraonnoro MCCJIe.n;OBaHM5I MoryT 6bITb
MCrrOJIb30BaHbI B yqe6HoM npouecce npn rrpenonaaannn Me)l{.n;yHapo.n;Ho-rrpaBOBbIX
.n;MCU:MrrJIMH B BbICWMX YQe6HbIX 3aBe.n;eHM5IX POCCMHCKOH <f>e.n;epaU:MM M Pecrry6JIMKM
A3ep6aH.n;)I{aH. )l;MccepTaU:M5I Mycradiaesoji H.M. na revy: «Mexoiyirapomro-npasoaaa
rr03MU:M5I Aaepfiatizracaaa B OTHoweHMM pediopxrapoaanna OOH» rrpe.n;CTaBJI5IeT C060H
u:eJIOCTHyIO HayqHo-KBaJIM(lmKaU:MoHHYIO pafiory, B KOTOpOH peurensi aanasn,
MMeIOru:Me cyniecrsenaoe saa-reaae .n;JI5I HayKM M rrpaKTMKM Me)l{.n;yHapo.n;Horo rtpasa.
Pa60Ta COOTBeTcTByeT Tpe6oBaHM5IM, rrpe.n;'b5IBJI5IeMbIM K KaH.n;M.n;aTCKMM .n;MccepTaU:M5IM
5
n, 9 Ilorroxceaaa 0 rropszuce npacyzcnenna y-rensrx creneneii, yTBep)I(,n:eHHbIM
Ilocranoanenaev Ilpaaurenscrsa POCCI1MCKOM <l>e,n:epaU:1111 OT 24 CeHT5I6p51 2013 r.
N2 842 (c 113MeHeHI151MI1 na 2 asrycra 2016), a ee aBTOp 3acnY)I(I1BaeT npacyaoieaas
YlfeHoM CTeneHI1 xaazmnara IOpl1,n:l1lfeCKI1X naytc no cneuaansnocra 12.00.10
Meacnyaaponaoe npaao; Eaponeacxoc npaso.
COHCKaTeJlb HMeeT 9 onyfinmcoaanmax pa60T no 'resre naccepranau, 4 113
KOTOpbIX orrytinaxonansr B penenaapyevsrx HaYlfHbIX 113,n:aHI151X 113 nepe-nrn BAK:
«Axryansnsre npofinexrsr POCCI1MCKOrO npasa», «EBPa3I1MCKI1M ropnznrsecxait »cypaan»
11 «Ilpaso 11 rocynapcrso: TeOpl151 11 npaKTI1Ka».
HaH60Jlee 3HaqHMble HaYQHbIe pa60TbI no 'resre ,lJ.HCCepTaQHH, B normoti
Mepe OTpa)l(aIOII.J;l1e nOnO)I(eHI151, BbIHOCI1Mble na 3aII.J;I1TY, 11 BbIBO,n:bI zmcceprauan:
1. Mycraoaesa H.M. OOH 70 ner cnycra: BbI30BbI COBpeMeHHOCTI1 11
Heo6xo,n:I1MOCTb perpopnu II EBpa3I1MCKI1M IOpl1,n:l1lfeCKI1M »cypaan. - 2016. - N2 2 (93).
- C. 51-53. (0 ,4 n.n.). B crarse paCCMaTpI1BaIOTC5I OCHOBHbIe rrpaopnrernsre
HanpaBneHI151 perpopvs: OOH, auanaaapyercs nearensnocrs COBeTa ne30naCHOCTI1
OOH, BbI):(Bl1raIOTC5I npe,n:nO)I(eHI151 no ero perpopve, a TaK)I(e ,n:OKa3bIBaeTC5I
Heo6xo,n:I1MOCTb peoopaennoii Mo,n:epHI13aU:1111 npaB03aII.J;I1THOM ,n:e5lTenbHOCTI1 OOH 11
Heo6xo,n:I1MOCTb Koop,n:I1HaU:1111 ee ,n:eMCTBI1M no sonpocav nonnepscaaaa
Me)I(,n:yHapo,n:Horo Ml1pa 11 6e30nacHocTI1 C ,n:pyrl1MI1 Me)I(,n:yHapo,n:HbIMI1
Me)I(npaBI1TenbCTBeHHbIMI1 OpraHI13aU:I151MI1.
2. Mycradiaesa H.M. COBeT ne30naCHOCTI1 OOH KaK rrpaoprrrer pedropvsr
OOH II Axryansnsre npo6neMbI POCCI1MCKOrO npasa. - 2016. - N2 2 (63). - C. 206-214.
(0,6 n.n.). B crarse paCCMaTpI1BalOTC5I B03MO)I(Hble Mo,n:enl1 ycoBeprneHCTBOBaHI151
,n:e5lTenbHOCTI1 COBeTa ne30naCHOCTI1 OOH, a I1MeHHO - ero CTpyKTypHa51
Mo,n:epHI13aU:I151, npofinenaraxa patio-tax MeTo,n:OB, BKnIOlfa51 I1CnOnb30BaHI1e I1HCTI1TYTa
rrpasa BeTO, a TaK)I(e aHaflI13I1pYIOTC5I n0311U:1111 rocynapcrs-anenoa OOH no sonpocy
perpopsrsr COBeTa ne30naCHOCTI1.
3. Mycradiaena H.M. Meacrtynaponao-npaBOBa51 n0311U:1151 A3ep6aM,n:)I(aHCKOM
Pecnytimncn no perpopue OOH: OCHOBHble HanpaBneHI151 11 peKoMeH,n:aU:1111 II Ilpaso 11
rocynapcrso: TeOpl151 11 npaKTI1Ka - 2016. - N2 1 (133). - C. 126-129. (0,5 n.n.). B
crarse ananasapyerca Me)I(,n:yHapo,n:Ho-npaBoBa51 n0311U:1151 A3ep6aM,n:)I(aHCKOM
6
Pecny6JIHKH no perpopue OOH, OCHOBHble npe,IJ;JIO)l(eHH5I KOTOpOH 6bIJIH
CepOpMHpOBaHbI B nepHO,IJ; pa60TbI CTpaHbI B COBeTe Ee30naCHOCTH OOH B xaaecrse
HenOCT05IHHOrO -mena, C epOKyCOM na np06JIeMbI MHpa H 6e30naCHOCTH, 60pb6y C
Me)l(,IJ;yHapO,IJ;HbIM TeppopH3MOM H 3aInHTOH npas qeJIOBeKa, a TaK)I(e Heo6xo,IJ;HMOCTblO
KOHCTpyKTHBHoro ,IJ;HaJIOra OOH C Me)l(,IJ;yHapO,IJ;HbIMH perHOHaJIbHbIMH
opraHH3aUH5IMH.
4. Mycrarpaeaa HJ1. Ilpo6JIeMbI pediopsraposanaa COBeTa Besonacnocra
OOH II EBpa3HHCKHH IOpH,IJ;HqeCKHH »cypnarr. - 2014. - N2 10 (77). - C. 57-58. (0,2
n.JI.). B crarse paccvarpnaaerca sonpoc perpopxmponanna COBeTa Eeaonacnocrn
OOH KaK rJIaBHOrO oprana, OTBeTCTBeHHoro sa nO,IJ;,IJ;ep)l(aHHe Me)l(,IJ;yHapO,IJ;HOrO MHpa
H 6e30nacHocTH, npe,IJ;JIaraeTC5I epOpMHpoBaHHe MexaHH3Ma MOHHTopHHra H
nepHO,IJ;HqeCKHX 0630pOB HCnOJIHeHH5I peIIIeHHH COBeTa Eesonacnocra
rocy,IJ;apCTBaMH-qJIeHaMH, npOBO,IJ;HTC5I aHaJIH3 YCTaBHblx B03MO)l(HOCTeH COBeTa
Besonacaocrn no npHMeHeHHIO npHHy,IJ;HTeJIbHbIX xtep K rocynapcraav
npaBoHapyIIIHTeJI5IM, He HCnOJIH5I1OInHM pe30JIIOUHH COBeTa Ee30naCHOCTH OOH.
Ha tJ;HccepTaU;HIO H auropcrpepar UOCryUHJlH OT3hIBhI:
IlOJIO)l(HTeJIbHbIH OT3bIB na anroperpepar, nO,IJ;nHCaHHbIH ,IJ;OKTOpOM
lOpH,IJ;HqeCKHX nayx, nporpeccopoxr AJIHeBbIM A.M., ,IJ;eKaHOM IOpH,IJ;HqeCKOrO
epaKyJIbTeTa Eaxancxoro rocyrtapcraennoro ynnaepcrrrera, CO,IJ;ep)l(HT nOJIO)l(eHHe 0
TOM, B033peHH5I rocy,IJ;apCTB-qJIeHOB na perpopvy OOH OTJIHqaIOTC5I nopoii
Kap,IJ;HHaJIbHbIM 06pa30M. B ::nOH CB5I3H, lOpHcTaM-Me)l(,IJ;yHapO,IJ;HHKaM H ,IJ;HnJIOMaTaM
Heo6xo,IJ;HMO 3HaTb OCHOBHble TeH,IJ;eHUHH perpopvennoro npouecca OOH, a TaK)I(e
n03HUHH rocy,IJ;apCTB-qJIeHOB OOH no 3TOMy CJIO)l(HOMY H npornsopenasony
sonpocy. BbI60p asropov 3TOH np06JIeMbI 06b5ICH5IeTC5I, CO sceii OqeBH,IJ;HOCTbIO, TeM,
qTO OHa HMeeT cepr.esnyto 3HaqHMOCTb KaK B TeOpeTHqeCKOM, TaK H B npaKTHqeCKOM
nnaae. TeKCT npe,IJ;CTaBJIeHHOrO asropedrepara ,IJ;HCCepTaUHH JIOrHqHO crpyxrypaponaa
H COOTBeTcTByeT Tpe6oBaHH5IM, npe,IJ;b5IBJI5IeMbIM K nO,IJ;06HbIM pa60TaM. MCXO,IJ;5I H3
aHaJIH3a ero CO,IJ;ep)l(aHH5I, MO)l(HO yCTaHoBHTb, qTO uerrs H 3a,IJ;aqH ,IJ;HCCepTaUHOHHoro
HCCJIe,IJ;OBaHH5I nOJIHOCTblO BbIIIOJIHeHbI, MaTepHaJI H3JIO)l(eH aBTopOM nOCJIe,IJ;OBaTeJIbHO
C npHBJIeqeHHeM IIIHpOKoro xpyra HopMaTHBHbIX H ,IJ;OKTPHHaJIbHbIX HCTOqHHKOB H C
7
,n:OKTOpOM
KacPe,n:pOH
nozmncaaasrsna asroperpepar,
MaMe,n:OBbIM P.<1>.,
OT3bIB
,n:Oll,eHTOMnayx,
apryMeHTIfpOBaHHbIM nsrpaaceaaexr C06CTBeHHOH nosIfll,IfIf rro paCCMaTpIfBaeMbIM
BOrrpOCaM.
TaK)Ke B OT3 bIBe OTMeLIaeTC5I HayLIHa5I HOBIf3Ha naccepramor, KOTOpa5I
3aKJIIOLIaeTC5I B TOM, LITO srrepnsre B HayLIHoH mrreparype B pavxax cnennansnoro
IfCCJIe,n:OBaHIf5I aBTOp CMOr CIfCTeMaTIf3IfpOBaTb If CTpyKTypIfpoBaTb OCHOBHbIe
rrpasossre acnexrsr npouecca pecPOPMbI OOB -repes npnsay rrpeztnoaceaaii If
pexoraenztaunii OTHOCIfTeJIbHO MOJIO,n:Oro LIJIeHa Oprannsauau - A3ep6aH,n:)KaHCKOH
Pecnyfinaxn, CcPOpMyJIIfpOBaHHble CTpaHOH B OCHOBHOM B nepnozt ee pa60TbI B
KaLIeCTBe HerrOCT05IHHOrO LIJIeHa COBeTa Ee30rraCHOCTIf OOB B 2012-2103 rr. Oco6o
OTMeLIaeTC5I TOT cPaKT, LITO MHOrIfe IfCrrOJIb30BaHHble B pafiore ,n:OKyMeHTbI
IfCrrOJIb3YIOTC5I snepssre If coztepxcar 3HaLIIfTeJIbHbIH 06beM nay-msrx ,n:aHHbIX.
)J,OCTOBepHOCTb pe3YJIbTaTOB IfCCJIe,n:OBaHIf5I 06yCJIOBJIeHa TeM, LITO B pafiore ,n:eTaJIbHO
rrpOaHaJIIf3IfpOBaHbI pe30JIIOll,IfIf Teaepansnoit ACCaM6JIeIf If COBeTa ne30rraCHOCTIf
OOB, a TaK)Ke peurenas Meaoiyaaponaoro Cyzia OOB. B zmcceprauaa rrpIfBo,n:5ITC5I
CCbIJIKIf na Me)K,n:yHapo,n:Ho-rrpaBOBble IfCTOLIHIfKIf If 3aKOHo,n:aTeJIbCTBO
A3ep6aH,n:)KaHCKOH Pecnyfinmca.
IlOJIO)KIfTeJIbHbIH OT3bIB na asropediepar, nozmacaansrfi ,n:OKTOpOM
IOpIf,n:IfLIeCKIfX nayx, npooeccopov BaJIeeBbIM P.M., nporpeccoposr xarpenps:
Me)K,n:yHapo,n:Horo If esponericxoro npasa Ka3aHCKOro clle,n:epaJIbHoro ymraepctrrera,
conepaorr 3aMeLIaHIfe 0 TOM, LITO paszten «MeTo,n:OJIOrIfLIeCKa5I OCHOBa nay-moro
IfCCJIe,n:OBaHIf5I» Mor 6bI conepacart, 60JIee noztpofiastii 0630P MeTo,n:OB IfCCJIe,n:OBaHIf5I B
,n:Ifccepranna.
B OT3bIBe TaK)Ke OTMeLIaeTC5I, LITO asropedrepar zmcceprauaa Mycrarpaeaoti H.I1.
a,n:eKBaTHO orpaxcaer conepacanae IfCCJIe,n:OBaHIf5I, ero OCHOBHbIe rrOJIO)KeHIf5I If
BbIBorrsr, OTJIIfLIaeTC5I apryMeHTIfpOBaHHOCTblO noamnm COIfCKaTeJI5I If
ncuepnsmaronnne xapaxrepov If3JIO)KeHIf5I MaTepIfaJIa. Pe3YJIbTaTbI IfCCJIe,n:OBaHIf5I
IfMelOT 3HaLIIfMOCTb, KaK ,n:JI5I npaxrn-recsoro npaxrenenaa, oco6eHHO B CBeTe
Heo6xo,n:IfMOCTIf BbIpa60TKIf 06:merrpIfeMJIeMOH cPOpMyJIbI rro pedropne OOB, TaK If ,n:JI5I
y-refiaoro npouecca.
IlOJIO)KIfTeJIbHbIH
8
Me~~YHapO~Horo rry6nM~HorO rrpaBa EaKMHcKoro rocy~apcTBeHHOrO yHMBepcMTeTa
(ErY), conepaorr nonoacenae 0 TOM, qTO asropeoepar naer ~OCTaTO~HO normoe
npencrasnenae 0 coztepxcannn zmcceprauaa. B HeM qeTKO crpopsrynaposanu nenn M
aana-m zmcceprauaoanoro Mccne~OBaHH5I, y6e~HTem~HOOTMe~aeTC51HOBH3Ha pa60TbI,
~eTKO npeztcraanensr norroxceaaa, BbIHOCHMble na 3aW:HTy.
B OT3bIBe 'ratoxe OTMeqaeTC5I, qTO axryarrsnocrs H36paHHOH: aBTopOM TeMbI He
BbI3bIBaeT COMHeHHH:, ocofienno B KOHTeKCTe nocnernrnx C06bITHH: Me~~YHapO~HOH:
~M3HH, xoropsre rro rrpaay xroryr 6bITb pacuenensr KaK HOBbIe yrpossr
Me~~YHapO~HOMY MHpy H 6e30rraCHOCTM. Eopsfia C HHMM npermorraraer
csoenpesremrsre H 3epcPeKTHBHble ~eH:CTBH5I OOH, KOTOpa51 sa BpeM5I CBOeH:
~e5lTenbHOCTH He nperepnena a~eKBaTHbIX H3MeHeHHH:, M TeM caMbIM nyacztaerca B
CKOpeH:WeH: Mo~epHH3aQHH. 3Ta Heo6xo~MMOCTb rrO~TBep~~aeTC5I CerO~H5I BceMM
rocynapcrsaraa-uneaaera OOH, B TOM -mcne H A3ep6aH:~~aHCKOH: Pecnytinaxoii.
C 3TOH: TO~KH 3peHH5I pafiora H.M. Mycrarbaeaoii HMeeT raioxe npaxrnvecxoe
3Ha~eHHe, BBH~y Toro, qTO ~eTMbHbIH: aHMH3 npoexroa He 'ronsxo Aaeptiaiinacaaa, HO
H ztpyrnx rocynapcrs-nneaos, paana-msrx excneprnsrx rpyrrrr rro pediopae OOH, a
raioxe noncacenaa H BbIBO~bI, npencraanennsre asropov B pafiore, MoryT 6bITb
acnonsaonaasi B 6y~yw:eM npn nenocpencrseanoii peMH3aQMH npouecca
pecPopMHpOBaHH5I OpraHH3aQMH.
BbI60p O«l>HUH3JIbHbIX onnOHeHTOB H Be,lJ,ymeH opr3HH33UHH
060cHoBbIBaeTc5I HarrpaBneHH5IMM M oco6eHHOCT5IMH HX Mccne~OBaHHH:, a ratoxe
crreQHMbHOCTblO 12.00.10 - Meacnyaaponaoe npaso; EBpOrreH:CKOe npaso, rro KOTOpOH:
nsmomrena pafiora COMCKaTen5l.
,lI;HccepT3UHoHHbIH COBeT OTMeQ3eT, QTO H3 OCHOB3HHH BbIDOJIHeHHbIX
COHCK3TeJIeMHCCJIe,lJ,OB3HHH:
C«I>OpMyJIHpOB3H3 HOBa51 nay-mas M~e51 0 Heo6xo~MMOCTM cPOpMMpOBaHM5I
pernonansno-rnofiansnoro naprnepcrna B uenax ofiecrreuenna Me~~YHapo~HoroMMpa
H 6e30rracHocTM, B CB5I3H C npeztnozceaaea Asepfiaiiztacana rro pacnmpeamo
COTpY~HH~ecTBa OOH C ~pyrMMH Me~~YHapO~HbIMH Me~rrpaBHTenbcTBeHHbIMH
(perHoHMbHbIMH) opraHH3aQH5IMH rro sonpocav o6eCrreqeHH5IMM Me~~YHapo~Horo
9
MHpa H 6e30rraCHOCTH, o60raI.IJ:aIOI.IJ:a51 nay-nrsre HCCJIe.ll:OBaHH5I rro perpopxre OOB,
nposeneaasre B Me)l(.ll:yHapO.ll:HO-rrpaBOBOM KOHTeKCTe;
paspafioraua HOBa51 3KCrrepHMeHTaJIbHa51 MeTO.ll:HKa, rr03BOJIHBIIIa51 BbI5IBHTb
KaqeCTBeHHO HOBbIe 3aKOHOMepHOCTH perpopereanoro npouecca OOB;
npen.noaceusr opnrmransnsre CY)l(.ll:eHH5I rro 3a5lBJIeHHOH TeMaTHKe,
06yCJIOBJIeHHbIe crre:U:H<pHKOH Me)l(.ll:yHapO.ll:HO-rrpaBOBoH rr03H:U:HH Aseptiaanacaaa rro
pedropxre OOB;
060CHOBaHa neofixonawocrt, perpopveaasrx rrpe06pa30BaHHH B COBeTe
Ee30rraCHOCTH OOB (C. 54-88) H .ll:e5lTeJIbHOCTH Me)l(.ll:YHap0.ll:HbIX rrpaB03aI.IJ:HTHbIX
opraaos CHCTeMbI OOB (c. 101-136), a TaK)I(e B sonpoce 60JIee TeCHoro
COTpY.ll:HHqeCTBa OOB C .ll:pyrHMH Me)l(.ll:YHap0.ll:HbIMH (perHOHaJIbHbIMH,
Me)l(perHOHaJIbHbIMH) Me)l(rrpaBHTeJIbCTBeHHbIMH opraHH3a:U:H5IMH rro sonpocaxr
3<pepeKTHBHoro ofiecne-renna Me)l(.ll:YHap0.ll:HOrO MHpa H 6e30rracHocTH (c. 136-161);
)J,OKa3aHa rrepcrrexrnanocrs HCrrOJIb30BaHH5I HOBbIX H.ll:eH B nayxe H npaxrnxe.
TeOpeTHQeCKaSl 3HaQHMOCTh Hccne)J,OBaHHSI otiocaonana TeM, qTO:
)J,aHa KOMrrJIeKCHa51 KpHTHKa KOH:u:err:U:HH TaK Ha3bIBaeMOH «ryaaaarapnoii
HHTepBeH:U:HH», C yxeroxr aHaJIH3a Hroronoro ztoxyxienra Bccsmpnoro caMMHTa 2005
rona, HOBOH KOH:u:err:U:HH coapeeremroro Me)l(.ll:YHap0.ll:HOrO npasa - «OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb
rro 3aI.IJ:HTe», KOTOpa51 orsepraer npaso na «ryMaHHTapHyIO HHTepBeH:U:HIO» H B03JIaraeT
na Me)l(.ll:YHap0.ll:HOe c006I.IJ:eCTBO rocynapcrn B :u:eJIOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb rro 3aI.IJ:HTe
npan qeJIOBeKa B cnynae HX npecrynnsrx HapyIIIeHHH, B pe3YJIbTaTe cOBepIIIeHH5I TaKHX
Me)l(.ll:YHap0.ll:HbIX npecrynnemni KaK reaouan, noeaasre npecrynneaaa, npecrynnenaa
nporna qeJIOBeqHOCTH H 3THHQeCKHe qHCTKH (c. 32-52);
npasreua'rem.no K npofinesra'rmce )J,HccepTaL(HH 3<1><I>eKTHBHO, TO ecrr, C
no.ny-reanesr 06na)J,alOIIJ;HX HOBH3HOH pesym.raroa acnom.aoaan KOMrrJIeKC
CYI.IJ:eCTByIOI.IJ:HX 06I.IJ:HX H cneuaam.nsrx MeTO.ll:OB nay-more rr03HaHH5I, B TOM qHCJIe
rrpHCYI.IJ:He HCCJIe.ll:0BaHH5IM B cdiepe IOpH.ll:HqeCKHX nayx xrerortu: cpaBHHTeJIbHO
rrpaBOBOH, CHCTeMHo-cTpyKTypHbIH, <P0PMaJIbHO-IOpH.ll:HqeCKHH, MeTO.ll:bI TOJIKOBaHH5I
HOpM npaaa, npasosoro MO.ll:eJIHpOBaHH5I H rrporH03HpOBaHH5I;
10
H3JIO~eHbI OCHOBHbIe MO.il,eJUI CTpyKTypHOH MO.il,epHH3aU:HH COBeTa
Oe30rraCHOCTH OOB, BbI.il,BHHYTbIe rocynapcrsaau-anenaan OpraHH3aU:HH, a TaK)l(e
pa3nHqHbIMH 3KcrrepTHbIMH rpyrrrraxra (c. 54-77);
npOaH3JIH3HpOBaHbI OCHOBHbIe aransr H cospevenasre TeH.il,eHU:HH
pediopxrenmrx rrpe06pa30BaHHHB OOB;
rrpnaenem.r npmrepsr Hcrronb30BaHH5I caHKU:HOHHoro MexaHH3Ma B pavxax
YCTaBHbIx B03MO)l(HOCTeH COBeTa Besonacnocra OOH C npennoacenaen ero
nocnezioaarensnoro H uenecoofipasnoro Hcrronb30BaHH5I K rocyzrapcraaw-uneaasr
OpraHH3aU:HH, He HCrrOnH5IIOIIJ:HM rrOnO)l(eHH5I pe30nIOU:HH COBeTa oe30rraCHOCTH OOH,
HMeIOIIJ:HX IOpH.il,HqeCKH 065I3aTenbHYIO cuny (C. 88-101);
BbIHBJIeHbI H npOaHaJIH3HpOBaHbI OCHOBHbIe npofinevsr perpopxrsr
rrpaB03aIIJ:HTHOrO MexaHH3Ma OOH (c. 101-136), a TaK)l(e C03.il,aHH5I pernonansno
rnofiansnoro rraprnepcrsa B pasncax COTpY.il,HHqeCTBa OOH C .il,pyrHMH
Me)l(.il,yHapO.il,HbIMH opraHH3aU:H5IMH B uenxx uaafionee 3~~eKTHBHoro ofiecneseaaa
Me)K.il,yHapO.il,HOrO MHpa H 6e30rracHocTH (c. 157-161);
paspafioraasr KOHKpeTHbIe rrpaxrnxecxae peKOMeH.il,aU:HH rro pa3peWeHHIO
TaKHX npofinexi CTOqKH 3peHH5I mrrepecon scero MHpoBoro c006IIJ:eCTBa.
3HaqeHHe nOJIyqeHHbIX COHCKaTeJIeM pe3YJIbTaTOB HCCJIeAOBaHHH AJIH
npaKTHKH nonrnepaeaaerca TeM, qTO:
cHcTeMaTH3HpoBaHbI Me)l(.il,yHapO.il,HO-rrpaBoBbIe rr03HU:HH KaK
A3ep6aH.il,)KaHCKOH Pecnytinnxa, TaK H ztpyrnx rocynapcrn-xneaoa OOH, B TOM -mcne
rrOCT05IHHbIX -meaoa COBeTa oe30rraCHOCTH, rro pe<popMHpOBaHHIO OOB; BbIBO.il,bI,
cnenaansre aa OCHOBaHHH H B pesynsrare TaKOH CHCTeMaTH3aU:HH xroryr
cnocoficrnosarr, BbIpa60TKe 06IIJ:errpHeMneMoH ~opMynbI perpopscsr OOH, B
pesyrrsrare KOTOpOH OHa CMO)l(eT <pyHKU:HOHHpOBaTb KaK .il,eHCTBeHHbIH MexaHH3M
CHCTeMbI Me)l(.il,yHapO.il,HbIX OTHoweHHH;
paapafio'raasr H zianst KOHKpeTHbIe npaxrn-recxae peKOMeH.il,aU:HH rro
pa3peWeHHIO B03HHKaIOIIJ:HX npofinext B xozte B03MO)l(HbIX rrpe06pa30BaHHH B OOH,
CB5I3aHHbIX C rrpoTHBOpeqHBbIMH rr03HU:H5IMH rocyztapcra-unenos H B nepsyro osepezn,
rrOCT05IHHbIX -menoa COBeTa Eesonacnocrn OOH, rro cYIIJ:eCTBy HaMeqeHHbIX
HOBOBBe.il,eHHH.
11
060CHOBaHO, qTO peiuenne nOCTaBrreHHbIX B MCCrre.n:OBaHMM npofirrev n03BOrrMT
cdropaynaposan, B 6y.n:YIIJ;eM ofiuterrpaesoresryio rpoprayny pe4JopMbI OOB, C yserov
cOrrraCOBaHM.H npOTMBOpeqMBbIX MHTepeCOB M HaUMOHaJIbHbIX n03MUMH rocyztapcrs
-menos, qTO B CBOIO onepezrs, rpefiyer OT HMX B3aMMHbIX ycrynox M KOMnpOMMCCOB BO
MM5I MMpHOrO M 6e30naCHOrO 6y.n:YIIJ;ero nenoae-recraa.
Onemca ,LJ,OCTOBepHOCTH pe3YJlbTaTOB HCCJle,LJ,OBaHHH BbIHBHJla, qTO:
TeOpeTHqeCKHe BbIBO,LJ,bI .n:MCCepTaUMM nOCTpOeHbI aa aHaJIM3e MOHOrpa4JMH,
CTaTeH M3BeCTHbIX IOpMCTOB-Me:>K.n:yHapO.n:HMKOB B 06rraCTM Me:>K.n:yHapO.n:HOrO rrpana, B
qaCTHOCTM npaaa Me:>K.n:yHapO.n:HbIX OpraHM3aUMH M Me:>K.n:yHapO.n:HOH 3aIIJ;MTbI npas
-renonexa, onyfinmconanmrx KaK na pyCCKOM 513bIKe, TaK M MHOCTpaHHbIX 513bIKax no
resre zmccepratma nna no CMe:>KHOH npofinevaraxe.
nparcrnuecxae BbIBO,LJ,bI OCHOBbIBalOTCH na aHaJIM3e 06WMpHoro npasonoro
xrarepaana, nxmouatontero .n:OKyMeHTbI OOB, Me:>K.n:yHapo.n:HbIX
Me:>KnpaBMTerrbCTBeHHbIX perMOHaJIbHbIX opraHM3aUMH, ,[(eKrrapaUMIO TbIC.HqerreTM5I
OOB (2000 r.), ,[(oKrra.n: Tpyunsi BbICOKoro ypOBH.H no yrpoaav, BbI30BaM M
nepevenaa: «Eonee 6e30nacHbIH MMp: nama o6IIJ;a51 OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb» (2004 r.),
rtoxnaztst Teaepansnsrx cexperapeii OOB, sxmo-raa ,[(oKrra.n: KOcPM AHHaHa «ITpM
60rrbweH caofiorte: K pa3BMTMIO, fieaonacnocrn M npasav -renonexa ztns scex» (2005 r.),
Hroronsrii .n:oKyMeHT Bcexmpaoro caMMMTa (2005 r.), Ilnan .n:eHcTBM5I Bepxosnoro
KOMMccapa OOB no npaaaxr -renoaexa (2005 r.), ,[(oKrra.n: Tenepansnoro cexperaps
«PerMOHaJIbHO-rrro6aJIbHOe naprnepcrso B ofinacrn 6e30nacHocTM: npofinesrsr M
B03MO:>KHOCTM» (2006 r.), ,[(oKrra.n: KOHcyrrbTaTMBHoH rpyrmsr sxcnepron no 0630py
MMpOcTpoMTerrbHoH apxnrexrypsr (2015 r.), peWeHM.H Mcaoiyaaponaoro Cyzta OOB, a
TaK:>Ke rrpeztnoxcemra M pexonennanaa no ycosepurencrsoaamno ornerrsnsrx BM.n:OB
ztesrrensnocra OpraHM3aUMM, BbI.n:BMHYTbIX A3ep6aH.n::>KaHCKOH Pecnyfirnncoii M
.n:pyrMMM rocyztapcraawa-aneaaaa.
HCnOJlb30BaHbI MaTepMaJIbI 0cPMUMaJIbHOrO caiira OOB M MMHMCTepCTBa
nnocrpamrstx zten A3ep6aH.n:)I<aHCKOH Pecnytinaxa.
12
JIHqHbIH BKJIa,1l; COHCKaTeJIH COCTOHT B:
B HenOCpe,n:CTBeHHOM yuacrnn B nOJIyqeHHH ,n:aHHbIX ,n:JI5I aHaJIH3a, B ofipafiorxe,
HHTepnpeTaU:HH, CHCTeMaTH3aU:HH H CTpyKTypHpoBaHHH nOJIyqeHHbIX ,n:aHHbIX;
nO,n:rOTOBKe H ny6JIHKaU:HH nay-msrx crareii no TeMe zmccepramronnoro
HCCJIe,n:OBaHH5I B peneaaapyexn,ix nay-msrx H3,n:aHH5IX H3 nepe-ms BAK.
Ha sacenanaa 9 MapTa 2017 rona zmcceprartaoanuit COBeT npHH5IJI pemenne
npncyrnrrs ysenyro crenens xanztanara IOpH,n:HqeCKHX nayx Mycradiaeaoii Ha,n:)I(H6e
Hnsrap KbI3bI.
ITpH nponezreana TaHHoro rOJIOCOBaHH5I zmccepraunonnsrii COBeT B KOJIHqeCTBe
14 qeJIOBeK, H3 HHX 7 ,n:OKTOpOB nayx no cneU:HaJIbHOCTH paccvarpaaaevoti
zmccepranaa, yqaCTBOBaBwHx B sacenamm, H3 21 qeJIOBeKa, BXO,n:51III:HX B COCTaB
COBeTa, nporOJIOCOBaJIH: sa npacyscnernre yaenoii CTeneHH - 14 (uersrpaazruart.)
qeJIOBeK, npoTHB - HeT, He,n:eHcTBHTeJIbHbIX 610JIJIeTeHeH - HeT.
I1PELJ:CELJ:ATEJIb
LJ:HCCEPTAIJ;HOHH
9 xrapra 2017 1.
),1l;OKTOP IOpH,1l;HQeCKHX nayx,L/ nporpeccop BbIJIermaHHH A.H.
KaH,1l;H,1l;aT IOpH,1l;HQeCKHX nayx,
nouerrr HBaHoB LJ:.B.