Slide 1
Financiamiento Privado de Infraestructura, Mercado de CapitalesFinanciamiento Privado de Infraestructura, Mercado de Capitales yyGarantGarantíías Financierasas Financieras
Ellis J. Juan
Banco Inter-Americano de Desarrollo (BID)
19 y 20 de febrero de 2009
México, Distrito Federal.
PRIMER ENCUENTRO TPRIMER ENCUENTRO TÉÉCNICOCNICOSOBRE LA ESTRUCTURACISOBRE LA ESTRUCTURACIÓÓN DE PROYECTOS DE ASOCIACIN DE PROYECTOS DE ASOCIACIÓÓNN
PPÚÚBLICOBLICO--PRIVADAPRIVADA
Slide 2
Esquema general de la presentaciEsquema general de la presentacióónn
I. BID : Rating Crediticio y Status de Acreedor PreferenteII. Bancabilidad de Proyectos: Volatilidad de Cash FlowsIII. Analisis de Riesgos (desde el punto de vista de la
Mobilizacion de Capital Privado -- Comite de Creditode Bancos)
IV. Mitigacion de Riesgos (opciones de mitigacion deriesgos disponibles)
V. BID: Apoyo a estructuras APPsVI. BID: Garantias y DerivadosVII. BID: Casos
Slide 3
BID:BID: CreditCredit RatingRating y Acreedor Preferentey Acreedor Preferente
� Global Credit Rating AAA : Fitch, Moody’s & Standard Poors
� Los Estados Unidos Mexicanos (EUM) han sido miembros accionistas delBID desde su creación en 1959. En toda la historia del BID, los EUMsiempre han pagado sus obligaciones al BID y nunca han estado endefault con el BID inclusivo durante las varias crisis que ha atravesado elPaís.
� Hasta hoy el BID ha financiado 10 proyectos del sector privado enMéxico de los cuales tres están repagados, cuatro en fase de reembolsoy tres en proceso de desembolso o otorgamiento (garantía). Solo unode esos proyectos (Energia, IPP) entró en default por un periodo de seismeses.. La situación se resolvió y el proyecto empezó a generar nivelesde ingresos suficientes para pagar su deuda con el BID y finalmente fuecomprado por una compañía quien prepagó la deuda con el BID.
Slide 4
PC (project completion)
InvestmentInvestment
DebtDebt
EquityEquity
Basic StructureBasic Structure ::
Capital Markets:Capital Markets: LongLong--Term FinancingTerm Financing
Cash FlowsCash Flows
US$US$
YearsYears
� Repayment of Debt is based on project cash-flows (non-recourse to sponsors)� Relatively high initial investments� Need for longer debt tenors to justify IRR tosponsors
� Repayment of Debt is based on project cash-flows (non-recourse to sponsors)� Relatively high initial investments� Need for longer debt tenors to justify IRR tosponsors
BancabilidadBancabilidad de Proyectos : Volatilidad Cashde Proyectos : Volatilidad Cash FlowsFlows
Slide 5
PC (project completion)
Investment
Debt
Equity
Basic StructureBasic Structure ::
Capital Markets:Capital Markets: LongLong--Term FinancingTerm Financing
Cash Flows (e)Cash Flows (e)
US$US$
YearsYears
Cash Flows realCash Flows real
Risk Mitigation products : Minimize cash flows downwardRisk Mitigation products : Minimize cash flows downwardfluctuations (ability to repay principal + interest)fluctuations (ability to repay principal + interest)
Key driver: Cash Flow predictability
BancabilidadBancabilidad de Proyectos : Volatilidad Cashde Proyectos : Volatilidad Cash FlowsFlows
Slide 6
AnAnáálisis de Riesgos: Identificacilisis de Riesgos: Identificacióónn
Riesgos Relacionados al ProyectoRiesgos Relacionados al Proyecto(relativamente manejables por inversores y(relativamente manejables por inversores y
prestamistas)prestamistas)
• Construcción y Puesta en Marcha (costode ingeniería y construcción / plazo deconstrucción)
• Riesgo Operacional(know how técnico y operativo)
• Riesgo de Crédito(project leverage)
• Riesgo Ambiental(pasivos pasados y futuros, retrasos,sobrecostos)
Riesgos No Relacionados al ProyectoRiesgos No Relacionados al Proyecto(no manejables por inversores y(no manejables por inversores y
prestamistas)prestamistas)
• Riesgo Politico(expropiación, violencia política,convertibilidad y transferencia demoneda)
• Riesgo Regulatorio(default de obligaciones contractualesdel Gobierno; ej., fórmulas de ajuste,derechos de vías)
• Marco Macroeconómico(cambios en el balance macro en cortoplazo; ej., tipo de cambio, inflación, etc.)
• Marco Legal(regla legal, ej., sistema judicial,procedimientos regulatorios y arbitraje)
Slide 7
AnAnáálisis de Riesgos: Estructuralisis de Riesgos: Estructura
OperadorPlanta Tratamiento
Agua
OperadorPlanta Tratamiento
Agua
AccionistasAccionistas
Prestamistas/Tenedores BonosPrestamistas/
Tenedores Bonos
OperadorOperador
EmpresaConstructoraEmpresa
Constructora
AutoridadConcedenteAutoridad
Concedente
Off TakeContract
Off TakeContract
Acuerdo deAccionistas
Contrato deConcesión
Contrato de Comprade Servicios
Usuariosfinales
Contrato deConstrucción
Contrato Operación yMantenimiento
Riesgos RegulatoriosRiesgos Regulatorios
Riesgos de Pago por ServicioRiesgos de Pago por Servicio
Riesgos deRiesgos deConstrucciConstruccióónn
RiesgosRiesgosOperacionalesOperacionales
Riesgos de MonedaRiesgos de Monedaextranjera yextranjera yrefinanciamientorefinanciamiento
Riesgos PolRiesgos Polííticos y Macroeconticos y Macroeconóómicosmicos
Suministro deAgua
Suministro deAgua
Riesgos RegulatoriosRiesgos Regulatoriosyy ClimaticoClimatico
TunelTunel EmisorEmisor OrienteOriente,, ObraObraPublicaPublica ((ConaguaConagua))
Slide 8
EvaluaciEvaluacióón y Mitigacin y Mitigacióón de Riesgosn de Riesgos
Privado/Publico
PublicoPrivado/ PublicoPrivado/Publico
Privado/Publico
PrivadoPrivado
Financiamiento enmoneda LocalDerivadosDeuda en tasa fija
Contrato deconcesiónGarantías Parcialesde Riesgo.Garantias parcialesde credito (AAA)>Derivados
Seguro de RiesgoPolítico
Garantía deIngresos /VPN ConcessionGarantías Parcialesde Riesgo
EvaluaciónAmbiental
Contrato deOperación
EPC Contract andperformance bonds
Bajo (MEX)AltoBajo (MEX)AltoMedioBajoMedio
Generación deIngresos.Devaluacióninflación, capacidadde pago usuario
Pago de Aguatratada.3 entidadesresponsables delpago de tarifa. Noexiste presupuestomulti anual.
Expropiacióntransferenciaconvertibilidad ycese en lageneración deingresos
Generación deIngresos
Pasivos OcultosGeneración deingresos yaumento de costosde operación
Sobrecostos yRetrasos
RiesgoMacroeconómico
RiesgoRegulatorio(Caso PlantaTrataminento
Agua)
Riesgo PolíticoRiesgo deDemanda
RiesgoMedio ambiental
RiesgoOperación
RiesgoConstrucciónRiesgos
Efecto enFlujo de Caja
Impacto
Instrumento deMitigación
Asignación(allocation)
SoberanosNoSoberanos
Slide 9
BID :BID : SoporteSoporte FinancieroFinanciero parapara EstructuraEstructura APPsAPPs
ComponenteSector PublicoComponenteComponente
SectorSector PublicoPublicoComponente
Sector PrivadoComponenteComponente
SectorSector PrivadoPrivadoPrivate Financial Markets
(Financing PPPs)Private Financial MarketsPrivate Financial Markets
(Financing(Financing PPPsPPPs))
Ventana SoberenaPrestamos
Ventana SoberenaPrestamos
PPP ProjectPPP Project
Ventana SoberenaGarantias
Ventana SoberenaGarantias
Ventana Sub-NacionalPretamos y Garantias
Ventana Sub-NacionalPretamos y Garantias
Ventana PrivadaGarantias
Ventana PrivadaGarantias
Ventana PrivadaPrestamos
Ventana PrivadaPrestamos
Slide 10
� Ventana Soberana� Prestamos� Garantias
� Ventana Sub-Nacional (Estados y Municipios)� Prestamos� Garantias� Subordinada
� Ventana Privada� Prestamos� Garantias� Subordinada
BID :BID : SoporteSoporte FinancieroFinanciero parapara EstructuraEstructura APPsAPPs
Slide 11
BID:BID: GarantiasGarantias yy DerivadosDerivados
� Mezzanine Guarantee� Pool Guarantee� Rolling Guarantee� Maturity Guarantee
� Co-Wrap Guarantee with Co-insurance
AplicacionesAplicaciones::
Design the “optimal” partial credit enhancement for a given project in order toimprove its credit risk profile enough to capture private capital on adequate
terms & conditions
Design theDesign the ““optimaloptimal”” partial credit enhancement for a given project in order topartial credit enhancement for a given project in order toimprove its credit risk profile enough to capture private capitaimprove its credit risk profile enough to capture private capital on adequatel on adequate
terms & conditionsterms & conditions
Slide 12
BID:BID: GarantiasGarantias yy DerivadosDerivados
� Mezzanine Guarantee
� A “credit” loss protection enhancement with IDBproviding a guarantee for a specified mezzanine layerof credit risk, thereby elevating the overall transactionto investment grade on the local currency scale. It isanticipated that subsequent to the provision of themezzanine guarantee by the IDB, the issuer could seek,if warranted, a full wrap guarantee on the transactionfrom a private financial guarantor.
�� IllustrationIllustration: For a project bond, the IDB couldprovide a partial guarantee for an external liquidityreserve, which would pay out after thetransaction’s internal credit enhancement (such ascash reserves or sponsor recourse) has beenexhausted, but prior to the local investor’s capitalbeing at risk for the remaining exposure.
Slide 13
Project Revenues(High Credit RiskQuality Layers)
Project Revenues(High Credit RiskQuality Layers)
Layer of LowerCredit Risk QualityLayer of Lower
Credit Risk Quality
Transaction Reserves
� Over-collateralization
� Project Debt ServiceReserve Acount
� Liquidity Reserve(sponsors recourse)
PartialPartialGuaranteeGuarantee
(a portion ofthe credit losson thetransaction, --debt service)
Transaction (ReceivablesSecuritization )
Mitigation of the lower credit riskquality and improving thetransaction rating attractsparticipation of MonolineMonolineInsurers to provide aInsurers to provide a ““wrapwrap”” onthe whole transaction,improving further thetransaction credit rating.
BID:BID: GarantiasGarantias yy DerivadosDerivados
Slide 14
� Pool Guarantee for Asset-Backed orMortgage-Backed Bonds
– A partial credit enhancement product with IDB providing a guaranteefor a portion of principal and interest sufficient to offset potential lossesresulting from non-performing assets within the underlying collateralpool. The Pool Guarantee’s amount will be calibrated for eachtransaction to improve the project’s credit rating in a manner sufficientto attract targeted local investors.
•• IllustrationIllustration: A bank with a mortgage portfolio may pledgemortgage receivables as collateral to repay a bond issue.Although the mortgage collateral enhances the bond’s creditquality, the information on the collateral in emerging markets maynot be adequate (e.g. incomplete records of past performance)and as such, the collateral may not be sufficient to attract localinvestors to purchase the bond. The IDB could further enhance thebond with a partial credit guarantee in order for the bond toachieve a credit quality sufficient to interest targeted localinvestors.
BID:BID: GarantiasGarantias yy DerivadosDerivados
Slide 15
Pool Guarantee: CBOPool Guarantee: CBO,, Illustrative purposesIllustrative purposes
Source: Rating Agencies Methodology (Case Example)
1. Stressed Default Rates (%)
CollateralRating BBB A AA
AAA 0.50 1.00 1.50AA 1.00 1.50 2.00A 2.00 3.00 4.50BBB 6.00 11.00 13.00BB+ 22.00 30.00 40.00 Approximation to Required Credit EnhancementBB 24.00 32.00 42.00BB- 30.00 36.00 48.00
Desired Rating (CBO) A
Underlying Credit Quality of Pool (AVERAGE) BB+Stressed Default Rate for a A rating 30.00%Recovery Rate (AVERAGE) 25.00%Loss severity (1-recovery rate) 75.00%
2. Assets Recovery Assumptions Expected Loss 22.50%(Default Rate * Loss Severity)
EM Sovereign without guarantee 25%EM Sovereign with guarantee 40%(principal + 12 month interest)EM Corporate 20%
Minimum Amount of Credit Enhancement = 22.50%(for bond holders guaranteed payment ofinterest + principal)
Desired CBO Rating
(illustration purposes)
CBO (Collateralized Bond Obligations) for Emerging Markets (EM) Debt
Slide 16
• Rolling Guarantee
� A partial credit enhancement product with IDBproviding a guarantee of a specified number ofinterest and/or principal payments, on a rolling forwardbasis – i.e. the guarantee rolls forward to the nextinstallment date upon payment by the issuer of thecurrent installment -- so that the IDB guarantee coversa rising share of remaining debt service.
�� IllustrationIllustration: For a project or corporate bond issue whereinvestors perceive a potential risk associated with avariation in the debt service coverage at some pointwithin the overall bond tenor, or are uneasy about aperiod of heavy corporate expenditures, the IDB couldprovide a rolling guarantee to smooth out therepayment profile and allay investor concerns aboutpotential timing/cash flow issues.
BID:BID: GarantiasGarantias yy DerivadosDerivados
Slide 17
Rolling &Rolling & ReinstatableReinstatable GuaranteeGuarantee((CarreterasCarreteras))
Debt /Service
CoverageRatio
1.51.5
1.01.0
Outstanding Principal
Years
N N + I
Rolling Guarantee
DSCRDSCR
Slide 18
Rolling &Rolling & ReinstatableReinstatable GuaranteeGuarantee((CarreterasCarreteras))
Debt /Service
CoverageRatio
1.51.5
1.01.0
Outstanding Principal
Years
N N + I
DSCRDSCR
Liquidity Facility Guarantee
Slide 19
BID:BID: GarantiasGarantias yy DerivadosDerivados
� Maturity Guarantee
– A partial credit enhancement product with IDB offeringa put option to investors to refinance an issue atmaturity with the IDB -for the purpose of persuadinginvestors to accept longer maturities.
•• IllustrationIllustration: In certain emerging markets the interestrate environments are such that even for privateissuers with very strong credit quality, tenors longerthan three years, for example, are just notavailable. In these markets, the IDB could offerissuers a maturity guarantee, to attract localinvestors with an appetite for 3-year paper intolonger maturities, by providing them an exit ifdesired.
Slide 20
CapitalRepayment
Bullet %
Outstanding Principal
Years
N N + I
Maturity Guarantee
Bullet %
MaturityMaturity GuaranteeGuarantee::Riesgo de RefinanciamientoRiesgo de Refinanciamiento
Slide 21
CasoCaso : Chile, Santiago: Chile, Santiago--ValparaValparaíísoso((GarantiaGarantia concon MonolinerMonoliner))
• Concession awarded to a consortium led by ACS and SACYR Group(Spain) in 1998 in Santiago de Chile, Chile.
• The toll-road concession consists in the expansion and refurbishing of 110km linking Santiago-Valparaíso and Viña del Mar
• Investment program of US$ 450 million to be partly financed through a localcurrency bond issue for the equivalent of US$ 300 million.
• IDB provided a credit guarantee to enhance the bond´s rating to a levelacceptable to local institutional investors. The IDB is Guarantor of Recordfor up to US$75 million with the remaining amount provided by privateinsurers. FSA (USA based private insurer) acted as co-guarantor of thetransaction.
• The issue before the IDB/FSA credit enhancement has been rated Baa2 byMoody’s, which is the highest investment grade rating ever given to a tollroad project in Chile. This is also the largest infrastructure bond soldprimarily to Chilean pension funds and insurance companies, paying acoupon of 6.02 percent (Unidad de Fomento), with a maturity of 23 years.
• The issue was rated AAA by local rating agencies after the IDB/FSAenhancement. It was successfully placed in April 9, 2002
Slide 22
Case :Case : GranaGrana & Montero, Asset Backed& Montero, Asset BackedSecuritySecurity
� G&M Developer Group is the largest engineering services group inPeru with around US$200 million of total assets and US$180 million inrevenues. t is mainly dedicated to the business of engineering andconstruction services.
� It also provides petroleum services (fuel terminals, drilling,extraction), information systems, engineering and real estatedeveloping services. 70 years of history and excellent workcompletion track record.
� BBB (triple B) national scale rating as a corporate by Fitch andEquilibraim, local rating agencies
Slide 23
• Bond Profile� Amount: US$50,000,000� Term: 8 years� Grace period: 6 months� Amortization: Semi-annual principal and interest payment� Type of payment: Equal coupons (principal + interest),
mortgage style� Coupon amount: US$4.3 million (with 8.5% interest rate)� Final payment: October 2011� Shadow rating -AA/AA
• Guarantee Structure� Amount: Up to US$20 million by IDB and FMO� Coverage: Callable for the full amount as a back-stop
facility or reduction of principalunder consecutive events ofdefault
Grana & Montero : Asset Backed Security
Slide 24
Guadalajara Toll Road PCG (FARAC I)Guadalajara Toll Road PCG (FARAC I)
“RCO”(Consortium of Goldman Sachs & ICA)
Borrower
IDB PCGUS$400m (equiv)
Local currency Loanequivalent toUS$3.7billion
provided by BankSyndicate including
international &domestic lenders
Conveyance of TollCollections
Funding received fromSyndicated Loan
Legend:
Trust CollectingToll Revenues
Traffic Revenues
Backstops RCO forUS$400m principalrepayment
Lays off project risk for 6int’l banks pro-rata(PCG beneficiaries)
IDB PCG Exposure &Beneficiaries
Slide 25
Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo
Representación en México: 9138-6200
www.iadb.org